Identity – The Conference

This January I had the exciting opportunity to attend and present at the British Psychological Society Division of Clinical Psychology Conference in Manchester. Now I am not a clinical psychologist, so some may find my attendance odd, my background is philosophy, teaching and counselling and psychotherapy. However since I decided to go into Private Practice I have tried to learn from all who work in the various associated fields of mental health. I will talk later about my specific workshop on Bi identities but I do think it is important that for all the current talk of hierarchies in the SCoPed no one at the conference treated me as a “mere” counsellor but as a fellow highly qualified and knowledgeable professional.

Identity seems finally to have become visible to those in the talking therapies. For so long the focus was always on the individual, but in a way which erased that which makes us individuals. Systematic oppression was often dismissed in a “just try harder” approach, and gender, sexuality, race, disability, class and other identities barely touched upon in training or in practice.

The keynote speech at the conference was given by Professor Tom Shakespeare. He spoke, among other things, on the vital difference between being identified as and identifying as. The difference between identities which are embraced and identities which are imposed. Or, as a popular meme puts it, the difference between a cat sitting in a box, and trying to put that cat in a box. A lack of appreciation of this difference has led some to claim “they don’t see labels” an attitude of erasing differences and structural oppression which rather than bringing about equality encourages inequality.

Three images. The first has three chidlren standing on boxes to see over a fence, but the smallest child cant see over. In the second the boxes have been rearranged so the shorter children can see over, in the last image the boxes have been removed.

What I find most interesting about this visual representation of structural barriers is that it is very often shared without the third image. We are it seems more comfortable with offering support to an individual than considering which structures need to be dismantled to truly allow equity to exist.

From Professor Shakespeare exploring what identity is, to workshops on dismantling whiteness, the impact of being a visibly tattooed psychologist, and many others, over two days people explored the importance of agency and authenticity if we are do be our best selves. It strikes me that there has often been a cognitive dissonance, perhaps growing from the blank slate psychoanalysts who founded the talking therapies (who of course were anything but blank, they simply confused their identities, white, cis, male, heterosexual, with not having an identity). How can we ask those coming to therapy to be their authentic selves if we as practitioners are not being authentic ourselves? The wider question, of the impact of not trying to understand the complex systems of oppression and privilege people inhabit was also touched on many times. Two lines from my notes keep resurfacing in my thinking;

In order to construct the new do we have to reconstruct the old or is it a continuous process?


The self is constructed and continually under construction.

Perhaps they resonate with me because this is how I see the therapeutic process, not a hierarchical progress towards self actualization but a continual process of becoming, and being at peace with that which we are becoming. In the LGBT symposium where PHD students presented their research I was struck by the fact that data still suggests young LGBT people are struggling with this process in the face of a hostile world. But it may be that this is not a uniquely LGBT process, that all of us, with our unique identities, privileges and oppressions, need to find ways to navigate the continual process of being who we are.

In my next post I shall focus specifically on my workshop – Neither Fish nor fowl, the problems faced by Bi+ people when working with mental health professionals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.